Model	Pick	Confidence	Total · O/U 9.5	Result
AI consensus 8/8	CIN	59%	9.2 Under · 7/8	✓
GLM 5.2 56% on 517 graded	CIN	62%	9.5 Over ✗	✓
Claude Opus 4.8 58% on 549 graded	CIN	63%	8.6 Under ✓	✓
Grok 4.5 55% on 416 graded	CIN	59%	9.2 Under ✓	✓
DeepSeek V4 Pro 56% on 481 graded	CIN	58%	8.9 Under ✓	✓
Claude Sonnet 5 57% on 529 graded	CIN	60%	9.2 Under ✓	✓
GPT-5.6 Luna Pro 57% on 416 graded	CIN	58%	9.3 Under ✓	✓
Gemini 3.6 Flash 56% on 275 graded	CIN	57%	9.3 Under ✓	✓
Kimi K3 54% on 354 graded	CIN	57%	9.4 Under ✓	✓

Finals are revealed for everyone: the graded record is the product. Rose = the model broke from the consensus. O/U calls grade against the closing line (9.5); a push grades nothing.

Expert	Market	Pick	Price	Result
Hans Geevers PickDawgz · Handicapper	Winner	CIN	—	✓
Dimers Dimers · Ratings model	Winner	CIN	-135	✓
DRatings DRatings · Ratings model	Winner	CIN	-147	✓
CBS Sports Staff CBS Sports · Staff picks	Winner	CIN	-144	✓
Chris Ruffolo PickDawgz · Handicapper	Winner	CIN	-145	✓
Ryan Bunnell Pickswise	Winner	ATH	—	✗
Covers Consensus Covers · Community consensus	Winner	CIN	-159	✓

Captured from public sources and frozen at first pitch (named experts never edited after first capture; consensus pickers track the crowd until game time). A pick only grades when it existed before the game started.